James for publishing Master of the Universe, it would have been unjust for a court to transfer title to her because the infringing derivative work contained copyrightable elements separate from those created by Stephanie Meyer. To continue my prior example, if Stephanie Meyer had sued E. It is unlikely that a court would ever transfer title from an infringer to a copyright owner because (1) it's not necessary, and (2) in the case of a derivative work it may be unjust. > the transferal of rights over the tabs to the copyright holders may be granted by a judge James's copyright in the elements that didn't come from Twilight. But nor could Meyer publish Master of the Universe without infringing E. James could not publish Master of the Universe without infringing the Twilight elements owned by Stephanie Meyer. For example, Fifty Shades of Grey started out as a Twilight fanfiction by E. A derivative work, however, may contain its own separately copyrightable elements, even if it was made without permission. A literal copy, even one that took a long time to make, will not contain any separately copyrightable elements. If the tabs do not alter the original song in any way, then they are more like a literal copy than a derivative work. > The tabs do not alter the original song in any way, they are merely a derivative work. own the painting? Just own the copyright? Own none of it? It is definitely not clear to me that you should automatically own my painting, even if I infringed your property rights by trespassing. To be explicit, while the transferal of rights over the tabs to the copyright holders may be granted by a judge as part of reparation of harm done, I see no reason that the music publishers should presume to own the rights outright without the intervention of a court.įor one final example as to why we should not conflate intellectual works and physical property, if I were to trespass onto your land and paint a beautiful painting of your landscape (with supplies I own) and then leave without causing damage, do you. The tabs do not alter the original song in any way, they are merely a derivative work. However, with intellectual property, this is explicitly not the case. In the lawn mower and house painting case, the labor is fundamentally tied to the physical property being infringed. However, in the OLGA copyright case, the publishers can trivially force the infringers to no longer publish the tabs, undoing any further damage. Any attempt to do so would be labor intensive. Intellectual "property" rights are better thought of as intellectual monopolies granted for a limited time, and this is important because intellectual works have some very different properties that separate them from physical property.įor instance, in your examples, the lawn mower cannot easily "un-mow" the lawn nor the painters "un-paint" the house. Yeah, but copyright is not a form of traditional property right. > This isn't a crazy outcome and it matches up well with traditional property laws. It used to be pretty easy to find these files available online, but I suspect copyright holders cracked down on these communities much like they did with OLGA. gp4, etc.) which I would read and edit with TuxGuitar. Guitar Pro also had an active community (maybe it still does), and many users would contribute their own tabs in Guitar Pro's file format (.gp3. There is a commercial product called Guitar Pro, but I felt the open-source packages were good enough. The original programs look to be abandoned, but it seems that an open-source implementation is actively maintained here. Īnother program that my friends used to use is Power Tab. It looks like it may not be a maintained product, but the source is available if you want to tinker with it. The sound quality and features were adequate - sort of a low-fi MIDI sound where different timbres and instruments could be selected. I felt it suited my purposes - I could work out the rhythm and positioning with this program and play files in various formats. There were a few programs that I used in the past to write and playback my own tabs.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |